【直报网1月4日讯】（21世纪网）某直销企业总裁感叹：如果雅芳不行贿，我就不会坐那几年牢！有此感叹的应该是一大批直销企业老总，还有不计其数的直销从业人员。雅芳通过行贿影响中国直销立法，其单层次直销得以被确立，多层次直销被定性为非法传销。这几乎祸害了整个中国直销业，因为大家都是多层次直销，整整8年，大家就在这冒着被抓被罚的危险“戴着镣铐在跳舞”。雅芳区区以1000万元，就买断了中国直销业8年的发展。尤为可悲的是，这1000万元罚款，雅芳公关导致绝大部分企业1年的罚款都不止1000万。更为可悲的是，从未有人为止买单，雅芳罚款与中国受损直销企业半毛钱关系都没有，只是应付美国境内的惩处。更为可悲的是，雅芳恶果仍将延续。

CNDSN January 4th news [] (twenty-first Century net) president of a direct selling enterprise sigh: if Avon not bribery, I wouldn't sit that several years in prison! This exclamation should be a large number of direct selling enterprises mister, there are too many to count the direct marketing practitioners. Avon through bribery, influence Chinese direct legislation, the single level direct selling has been established, the multi-level direct selling are characterized as illegal pyramid selling. This is almost the entire China scourge of the direct selling industry, because everyone is a multi-level direct selling, exactly 8 years, everyone in this risked being arrested "fined wearing chains in the dance". Avon only to 10000000 yuan, to buy out the development Chinese direct selling industry for 8 years. Very sadly, this is a fine of 10000000 yuan, Avon PR leads to most of the enterprises have more than 1 years of a fine of 10000000. Sadly, has never been so far to pay, Avon fines and Chinese damaged half cents relationship of direct selling enterprises are not, just deal with the USA territory of punishment. Sadly, Avon consequences will continue.

以下文章内容来自：第一议题

The following article content from the first issue:

据业内资深媒体人士称，他身边至少有10位以上国内直销企业老总因涉嫌多层次直销而锒铛入狱。

According to industry of domestic deep media sources, his side at least 10 more than the domestic direct selling enterprises Mister on suspicion of multi-level direct selling and be chained and thrown into prison.

雅芳中国公司周三承认，2004年至2008年期间，雅芳中国的高层及员工曾向可帮助其获得直销经营许可、逃避罚款和压制官媒负面报导的中国官员行贿共9600笔，行贿总额165万美元(注：约为人民币1025万元)，为此同意支付1.35亿美元(约为人民币8.38亿元)就相关民事和刑事指控达成和解。

Avon China Company acknowledged Wednesday, during the period from 2004 to 2008, senior and staff had to Avon Chinese can help them to get China officials direct selling license, avoid fines and pressing state negative reports a total of 9600 pens bribery, bribery amount to $1650000 (Note: about 10250000 yuan), therefore agreed to pay $135000000 (approximately RMB 838000000 yuan) on the related civil and criminal charges of reconciliation.

和解的背后，却是雅芳只用了区区1000万元，就买断了中国直销业整整八年的发展，并且恶果暂时还不会结束。

Reconciliation is Avon behind, only a mere 10000000 yuan, to buy out the development Chinese direct selling industry for eight years, and the consequences of not yet ended.

雅芳这个中国直销界曾经的大姐大，对中国直销市场的影响却非常深远。著名直销专家、九方马传播机构董事长王万军指出：

The direct selling industry Avon Chinese once big sister, impact on the China direct sales market is very profound. Direct marketing experts, the famous nine Fangma communication agency chairman Wang Wanjun pointed out:

“尽管还未有消息证实雅芳贿赂门是否直接影响了直销立法，但‘雅芳模式’在法律上被采用，却给中国直销市场带来了重创。因为单层次直销的雅芳模式被直销法规釆用，而安利等95％以上的多层次直销模式被定性为非法传销，导致整个中国直销行业除雅芳外，都不得不‘戴着镣铐跳舞’，带来了种种弊端，严重阻碍了中国直销行业的发展。许多直销企业因此导致的罚款一年都不止1000万元。”

"Although there is no news that Avon bribery whether directly affect direct legislation, but 'Avon mode' is used in the law, brought a hit but to China direct selling market. Because the single level direct selling Avon mode is the direct selling regulations adopted, and the multi-level direct sales model above Amway 95% was characterized as illegal pyramid selling, causes the entire China direct selling industry in addition to Avon, have to 'dancing with shackles,' brings about many disadvantages, seriously hindered the development of the direct selling industry Chinese. Many direct selling enterprises therefore lead to fine a year more than 10000000 yuan."

早在2010年4月，王万军就撰问追问《谁为雅芳贿赂门买单》，但迄今没有谁为此担责。更可悲的是，雅芳的罚款，也只是应付美国境内的制裁，与中国受损的直销企业半毛关系都没有。而当年雅芳行贿三大将之一，甚至又进入了某拿牌直销企业任副总裁。

In early 2010 April, Wang Wanjun had written asking "who asked for Avon bribery bill", but so far no who therefore bear the responsibility. Sadly, Avon fine, only to cope with America territory of the sanctions, and Chinese damaged direct selling enterprises semi wool have no relationship. When Avon bribe one of three generals, and even entered the vice president is appointed to a draw direct selling enterprises.

在直销立法初期，就出现了雅芳模式和安利模式之争。前者代表单层次，后者代表占国际直销主流95%以上的多层次，中国直销企业企盼的直销立法也是开放多层次,但雅芳的单层次直销却成为了中国直销开放的模板。

In the direct selling legislation early, appeared Avon mode and Amway model debate. The former represents a single level, the latter represents the multi-level international sales accounted for more than 95% of the direct selling legislation China mainstream, direct selling enterprises expect is multi-level open, but the single level direct selling has become Avon Chinese direct open template.

直销立法过程中，被视为直销立法启动的第一次厦门会议，即由商务部牵头发起，时任商务部外资司副司长邓湛则一直走在直销立法的台前，并被视为关键性人物。此外，商务部条法司起到了更为重要的作用(条法司的职责是法规的制定和法律适用标准的释明)，其时被冠以“经济汉奸”的郭京毅一直任条法司副司长。“郭京毅邓湛窝案”事发后，人们才发现部分跨国公司通过向掌握法规制定大权的人士行贿，从法律保障上获得竞争的便利，甚至不惜牺牲市场原本的诉求。

Direct the legislative process, regarded as the first meeting of the Xiamen direct selling legislation initiated by the Ministry of Commerce, led by the then foreign secretary, deputy director of the Ministry of Commerce Deng Zhan has been walking in the direct selling legislation in front of the stage, and is seen as a key figure. In addition, Department of treaty and Law Department of commerce plays a more important role (Department of treaty and law is the responsibility of the Shi Ming formulation of laws and regulations and law application standard), at that time was called "economic traitor" Guo Jingyi has been appointed deputy director of the division of a law. "The Guo Jingyi Deng Zhanwo case" after the incident, people found that part of the Multi-National Corporation through the people to grasp the regulations of bribery to obtain the competitive power, from the legal protection of the convenience, even at the expense of the original market demands.

Direct selling regulations to market orientation, bring direct selling enterprises embarrassing situation, but also brought big challenge to law enforcement. Because of the multi-level direct selling market is an irreversible development way, and in the process of law enforcement in view of this way lead to irreversible, law enforcement can not strictly in accordance with the direct selling regulations to purge the market. To obtain a direct selling license only by way of direct selling enterprises, in fact used a multi-level direct sales model.

但直销法规有如悬在头顶的利剑，在一定程度上又成为地方管理部门牟利的工具。由于直销法规与市场实际需求的背离，导致法规难以执行，但毕竟有法律文本存在，这就使得一些地方管理部门在监管企业的时候获得了非常大的自由度。不管获牌企业还是非获牌企业都经常遭遇这种尴尬：“说你是直销你便是直销，即使是传销(事实上的多层次直销)也是直销；说你是传销你便是传销，即使是直销(事实上的单层次直销)也是传销。”尴尬的后果，则是需要企业付出高昂的公关成本。

But the direct selling regulations as hanging in the head of the sword, to a certain extent and become local profit management tool. As a result of direct selling regulations and market deviates from the actual demand, leading to regulations difficult to implement, but after all the existing legal texts, which makes a number of local management department to get a very large degree of freedom in supervision enterprises. No matter the brand enterprises and non licensed enterprises often encounter this kind of embarrassment: "you said you are selling is the direct, even the MLM (multi level in fact direct marketing is direct marketing); say you are MLM you is a pyramid scheme, even if is direct (single level direct selling is in fact) mlm." The awkward consequences, is the need to pay a high cost of enterprise public relations.

更严重的是，因为法规与市场的冲突，束缚了企业的发展，严重地牺牲了整个行业发展的速度。可以说，雅芳的1000万元罚款，买断了中国直销行业整整8年的发展。

More serious is, because of the conflict between regulations and market, constrained the development of enterprises, serious sacrifice of whole industry development speed. It can be said, a fine of 10000000 yuan Avon, bought out the full 8 years of development China direct selling industry.

令市场稍感欣慰的是，近日，有知情人透露，商务部正开会在重点讨论关于直销法律法规的修改意见，尽管主要是关于服务网点的法规修改，但这意味着相关部门终于意识到了法规与市场的冲突，并开始着手解决。

The market a little relief, recently, insiders said, the Ministry of commerce is a meeting to discuss about the legal laws and regulations direct modification opinion in focus, although the main is to modify the regulations about service outlets, but this means that the relevant departments to finally realize that the conflict rules and the market, and began to solve.

尽管中国直销市场因为一个雅芳而经历了阵痛，但是业内人士依然相信，中国直销市场将会探索出一条符合中国国情，及行业发展规律的道路。在这个倡导法治社会的今天，终归会有符合市场需求的法规出来。毕竟，依法治国，前提必须是良法才能治国。▲

Although China direct selling market because of a Avon and suffered the pains, but the industry still believe, will Chinese direct marketing to explore a line with the national conditions and the development of the industry China, rules of the road. In the advocacy of law society today, will have to meet the needs of market rules out. After all, the rule of law, rule of law can the premise must be. *

（原标题：震惊！超过10位直销企业老总因雅芳行贿门锒铛入狱）

(original title: shock! More than 10 direct selling enterprises Mister for Avon bribery be chained and thrown into prison)

责任编辑：小申

Editor: small Shen